City of Edinburgh
It takes a whole year’s Band D council tax from
135 households
to pay the chief executive’s salary of £195,905. Band D in City of Edinburgh was £1,448 in 2024/25, before water and sewerage.
The register
Who is paid what
| Officer | Salary | Employer pension | Other benefits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paul Lawrence printed as “P. Lawrence”Chief Executive (from 17.06.24) and Executive Director of Place (to 16.06.24) Excludes Returning Officer fees (£7,671 approved separately for 2024/25). | £195,905 | £34,479 | £1,806 |
| Amanda Hatton printed as “A. Hatton”Executive Director of Children, Education and Justice Services | £186,939 | £30,973 | £405 |
| Deborah Smart printed as “Dr. D. Smart”Executive Director of Corporate Services | £186,939 | £30,945 | £205 |
| Richard Lloyd-Bithell printed as “R. Lloyd-Bithell”Service Director - Finance and Procurement | £140,396 | £24,710 | £918 |
| Rose Howley printed as “R. Howley”Chief Social Work Officer | £124,840 | £21,972 | £0 |
| Gareth Barwell printed as “G. Barwell”Interim Executive Director of Place (from 29.08.24) Part year from 29.08.24; full-year equivalent salary £186,939. | £110,555 | £29,455 | £307 |
Basis A dash means the accounts did not disclose the figure. It does not mean zero. Employer pension is what the council pays into that officer’s pension on top of the salary. Where the accounts printed initials, the full name comes from the council’s own documents, and the methodology explains how.
The trajectory
What has actually happened to the pay
- Chief executive pay
- Band D council tax
Pay for comparative years is as the accounts disclosed it, which for a few councils is total remuneration rather than salary alone. Band D excludes water and sewerage.
Both lines start at 100 in 2019/20, so they can be read against each other: the gap between them is the gap between what the chief executive is paid and what the household bill has done since.
The whole senior team, salaries only
Basis Every officer in the council’s senior-employee table, with no £100,000 floor. Salaries as disclosed, never added up across a year where a figure is missing. Employer pension contributions appear against each officer above and are not in these totals. A star marks a year read from the following year’s accounts as its prior-year column. A few councils leave mid-year leavers out of that column, so a starred total can run slightly low.
The cohort
How many staff here are on the good money
948 employees were paid above £50,000 in 2019/20. By 2024/25 it was 2,827. Above £100,000 the count went from 25 to 25.
Basis The statutory £5,000-band disclosure covering all employees, counted above a fixed cash threshold as the accounts count it. Counting instead above the CPI equivalent of the 2019/20 threshold gives 948 then against 846 now, and the JSON carries that figure for every year. The backdated 2022/23 teachers’ pay award, paid in April 2023, pushes the 2023/24 figure up.
The goodbyes
Exit packages
City of Edinburgh disclosed 178 exit packages costing £10.4m over the six years to 2024/25.
Packages of £100,000 and over
| Year | Band | Packages | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021/22 | £250,001–£300,000 | 1 | £290,000 |
| 2023/24 | £250,001–£300,000 | 1 | £268,000 |
| 2019/20 | £200,001–£250,000 | 2 | £458,000 |
| 2020/21 | £200,001–£250,000 | 2 | £466,000 |
| 2021/22 | £200,001–£250,000 | 1 | £211,000 |
| 2024/25 | £200,001–£250,000 | 1 | £237,000 |
| 2019/20 | £150,001–£200,000 | 1 | £151,000 |
| 2020/21 | £150,001–£200,000 | 4 | £702,000 |
| 2021/22 | £150,001–£200,000 | 1 | £164,000 |
| 2023/24 | £150,001–£200,000 | 2 | £336,000 |
| 2024/25 | £150,001–£200,000 | 1 | £153,000 |
| 2019/20 | £100,001–£150,000 | 3 | £358,000 |
| 2020/21 | £100,001–£150,000 | 1 | £123,000 |
| 2021/22 | £100,001–£150,000 | 5 | £613,000 |
| 2023/24 | £100,001–£150,000 | 1 | £104,000 |
| 2024/25 | £100,001–£150,000 | 2 | £240,000 |
Basis Exit packages as the remuneration report discloses them, by cost band. For most councils the cost covers pension strain and added years as well as the money paid to the person leaving. The bands name nobody, and neither does this record. A dagger marks a year where some bands showed packages with no cost against them, so the total is a floor rather than the full figure.
The invisible payroll
What the council pays into pensions
Basis Employer contributions taken from the pension notes to the accounts. This is the council’s own money going in, not the staff’s. This is the local government scheme only. The teachers’ scheme is a separate payment to the Scottish Government and is not added in here, because the council never printed a combined total.
LGPS: Note 42.2 comparative, 'Employer's contributions payable to the scheme' £64,097k (£000s); excludes £5,358k contributions in respect of unfunded benefits shown separately. Teachers: Note 41 comparative, 'Amount paid to Scottish Government in respect of teachers' pension costs' £31,974k. No combined LGPS+teachers total printed.
Officers and members
The paid and the elected
2024/25, salaries as disclosed
Basis The officers’ bar is salary only, before employer pension contributions. The councillors’ bar is the total printed in the remuneration report.
Remuneration Report, 'Members' Salaries and Expenses' table (whole £): salaries £1,730,980; total £1,766,456. Expenses printed only as two components with no subtotal (claimed by councillors £325; paid directly by the Council £35,151), so expenses left null. 63 councillors stated in the Management Commentary.
Arm’s length
Pay in the companies this council owns
| Body | Post | Salary | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Edinburgh Trams Ltd | Lea Harrison Highest paid directorcorroborated | £460,445 | 2025 |
| Lothian Buses Ltd | Sarah Boyd Highest paid directorcorroborated | £226,000 | 2025 |
| Edinburgh International Conference Centre Ltd | Marshall Dallas Highest paid directorcorroborated | £199,365 | 2024 |
| Transport for Edinburgh Ltd | George Lowder Highest paid directorcorroborated | £139,000 | 2024 |
| Edinburgh Leisure | — Employees in band | £110,000 - £119,999 | 2024/25 |
| Capital Theatres | — Employees in band | £150,001 - £160,000 | 2024/25 |
Basis Read from each body’s own filed accounts. Several of them disclose a pay band and no name. Where the accounts, Companies House or the council’s own report put the identification beyond doubt, the name is given and the evidence recorded. Where they do not, the row stays exactly as printed.
This council as data: /api/scotland/city-of-edinburgh.json